When You Care Enough to Steal the Very Best

Brian Clark’s Copyblogger.com just won the 2007 Blogger’s Choice Award for Best Marketing Blog. If you do 1/10th of what this guy teaches (and he gives it away for free, folks) you’ll be rich. Which is why we were concerned to find out that someone seems to be stealing Brian’s stuff.

Google vs Article checker4

Not long ago we wrote Someone Out There is Swiping Nicholas Boothman’s Stuff – an article about content theft on the Internet. Now, we find out, someone is stealing Brian Clark’s stuff, too.

Don’t be too alarmed. It happens all the time. Still… this one had us scratching our heads more than most.

The stunning thing about the 2007 Blogger’s Choice Award is that Brian Clark’s blog even beat Seth Godin’s Blog. Seth Godin, in case you missed the memo, is God. (Want to save yourself a lot of money in the coming year that you might be tempted to spend on Internet marketing hucksters and pitchmen? Well, just stop doing it and instead read Brian Clark and Seth Godin – and don’t read anyone else).

But, back to our topic of plagiarism. Now, just so you don’t think we’re weird, we really don’t go snooping around hoping to find instances of Internet theft. Our excuse is that we’re writing an eBook about online copyright infringement, plagiarism and other seedy shenanigans. And, for that book, we need examples.

So we tested a phrase from an older Copyblogger article (don’t know how old, because, unless I missed it, Brian, who does everything right, doesn’t date his blog posts – which drives me insane).

The phrase (in case you want to play along at home, folks) was “I’m not talking about being famous like Tom Cruise.” It comes from a post he wrote about branding called, “How to be a Rock Star in Your Niche.”

If you plunk that sentence – “I’m not talking about being famous like Tom Cruise” – into Google you’ll get several results, most of them legitimate links back to Copyblogger. One, however, just completely mystified us – for many reasons.

Google vs Article checker

It would appear that a web site called KillerCopywritingBlog.com is “borrowing” Mr. Clark’s prose not only for this link – but pretty much throughout the entire blog. However, we could not find any attribution, nor so much as a thank you, to Brian Clark. What the heck?

Google vs Article checker2

Furthermore (and you should try this at home, kids), the KillerCopywritingBlog was downright unreadable – appearing to be a wild pastiche of clumsy copies and pastes. Hmm… truly, what is going on here?

Now, here’s the really seedy part. While KillerCopywritingBlog.com says that it belongs to the “world’s #1 website conversion expert Dan Lok” – it may well not belong to Dan, at all. Dan is a well known Internet marketing guru, who ranks #47 on the GuruDAQ.com’s “Internet Marketing Index.”

You see there are sites that simply scrape the content of other sites and slime themselves onto the Internet just for the heck of it. This one could be sliming Dan Lok’s name, as well. You never know.

And, that’s the part that makes us crazy – because many of the links actually do go to Dan Lok’s various marketing strategies. However, if you were going to steal Brian’s content and Dan’s name, wouldn’t you change all the links to your own destinations?

This whole site might just be someone’s idea of a nasty good time – sort of an Internet graffiti impulse. Or, it could be a kind of twisted affiliate marketing strategy – one that must cynically think that readers have no brain whatsoever. We’ll ask Brian and we’ll ask Dan and see if they can make some sense of it for us.

We’re just average business people trying to offer Internet research tips that are worthwhile and Internet marketing red flags that might make people stop and think. This one really made us stop and think.

Someone is stealing Brian Clark’s stuff – for no clear reason. And, if you check – you may well find they’re stealing your stuff, too.

6 comments ↓

#1 Brian Clark on 12.23.07 at 10:00 am

That’s the lamest scraper site I’ve ever seen. But, as I always say, follow the links to see who benefits…

#2 Michael Benidt on 12.23.07 at 11:58 am

Thanks Brian,
You said more in one sentence than we said in the whole article. “Follow the links….”
And, thanks for being transparent with contact information – we’re still looking to find an email address for Mr. Bok and you’ve already replied.
Readers: If you’d like a completely fresh approach to content theft, read Brian’s blog post called, “How to Steal Great Content Ideas” (legitimately, of course)

#3 Judy Sabah on 12.27.07 at 2:04 pm

Thanks so much for always helping me to learn! That is what I appreciate most about what you write. You help me gain more awareness about what to look out for, and help me learn new ways of doing things.

#4 Michael Benidt on 12.28.07 at 7:39 am

Thanks, Judy,
We learn a lot more from you than we could ever give back. You bring humanity to everything you do – which makes us want to continue to try to shed a little human light on this strange world of technology software, hardware and nitwits.

#5 Janice Byer on 12.29.07 at 7:33 am

Thank you for posting this and hopefully opening the eyes of others to the fact that copying someone else’s content is not a form of flattery… it is plagarism. Many people, including myself, have had to deal with this and it is so frustrating. I even wrote an article on my blog at http://docutype.org/blog/?p=11#more-11 after yet another round of dealing with a content thief. A longer, 3-part series of the article can be found on my website at http://www.docutype.net/articles/sitetheft1.htm. Spread the word… copying someone else’s content is a sign of laziness and just plain criminal!

#6 Clayton Shold on 12.31.07 at 4:05 pm

The first time I had an article “stolen” I was pretty miffed. Someone (with no contact info on their blog) had cut and pasted word for word a piece I did on the 2006 Olympics titled “Armchair Olympian”.
I had an author contact me as someone has submitted her work under his name to Salesopedia as his own. He later denied he sent it to me. In the stranger than fiction department, turns out the two knew each other!
Yes, this stuff is happening and it is not right. To chase it and police it may prove difficult and too time consuming to be worth the effort.

Leave a Comment